We may receive a commission when you use our affiliate links. However, this does not impact our recommendations.
In the first issue of Woodworking Magazine I wrote a half-page article titled “A Better Hinge” that sang the praises of the Amerock non-mortise hinges, which I have used for many years with great success. But today I’m considering withdrawing that recommendation.
During the summer I bought four of these hinges from my local Rockler for the cover project slated for issue 5. All the hinges were labeled the same, had the same price and were in the same bin at the store. When I unpacked them I noticed that two of them looked a little different. They were branded as Amerock but were labeled as “Made in China.” The other two were labeled “Made in USA.” Hmmmm.
After some debate, I decided to install both sets and see if there was any difference. It would be a fair test , same cabinet, same-size door, same wood, same installer.
I was not impressed with the Chinese-made hinges. The pin and barrel were unacceptably sloppy , one of them had almost an 1/8″ gap between the barrel and the top of the hinge pin. The Chinese hinge wiggled on its pin. The tight tolerances that I loved on the USA Amerocks was gone. The door even has a cheesier feel when you open and shut it.
I’ve asked Amerock if the company is going to offer both lines of hinges or if it is going to discontinue the USA hinges. When I receive a response, I’ll post it here. Until then, you might want to check your hinges before you pay for them and check the tolerances if they read “Made in China.”
Here are some supplies and tools we find essential in our everyday work around the shop. We may receive a commission from sales referred by our links; however, we have carefully selected these products for their usefulness and quality.
This is something I’ve been noticing in general about items manufactured in China. Tolerances tend to be within the range of "barely acceptable" to "acceptable" for the item, but seldom within the range of "high quality". At this point, I have ceased to buy anything from China that can be had from elsewhere, especially when precision matters (as with tools and hardware).